A look back on 2023 in the Green Party

 In the coming year we will win a controlling majority in councils around the country, including Bristol where the green party is the largest party but the city recently voted in a referendum not to be governed by an executive mayor but go to committee system.


How many campaigns have the Green Party won?


Still to win are:

Ella's law - Clean air human rights act.

In my opinion the party must become better at picking its battles and look outside of its horizon to ensure everyone is represented and that there is a clear plans for which legislation the parliamentarians put forward when they have the rare chance.

Defending the right to protest - This was a win the previous year and the government was forced to bring back some of the worst attacks as a new legislation.  In the coming year some of this will come into force.  We've seen people arrested for singing carols and climate activists sent to jail, and threatened with deportation.

Defending workers rights - Labour Party must be persuaded in this.  Elizabeth May MP has led the way through the anti scab Bill in the Canada parliament.

Defeating the Rwanda Bill - to be continued late January

Zane's law - a priority that we are working on

Stopping fossil fuel projects such as Rosebank - It was stopped but then rescued


Campaign "wins" include

High Speed 2 is dead.  It is not planned to reach Euston and phase 2 is cancelled.  The Green Party is calling for a public inquiry into the management of the project.

London has now extended the Ultra Low Emission Zone, despite dirty campaigning linked to the Conservatives.  Shamefully Kier Starmer has publicly criticised the Mayor.

Outer London now benefits from the bus routes we fought to save and new routes the London Loop.  New infrastructure is open such as Crossrail (the Elizabeth Line)

the APPG reparations has been formed and this has been adopted by XR as a 4th demand.

Fossil fuels are mentioned for the first time in the climate change framework.

The City of Sheffield has called for ceasefire and condemned Kier Starmer. Organisations are considering openly endorsing the Green Party and have invited Carla Denyer, Ria Patel, and Natalie Bennett onto platforms (they were hoping for Caroline Lucas.  locally greens have spoken and attended rallies too including a petition hand in by school strikers in Bristol which other MPs failed to turn up)

London Borough of Hackney has a policy to ban fossil fuels advertisements





How it feels to be Jewish in the UK at the moment

 I was hearing the deputy leader and democracy spokes person of the Green Party on LBC yesterday.  I am proud that we have one who does such a good job, alongside other spokes people, such as yesterday.  I have always cared deeply but the battle lines are frought on social media and we find ourselves in an information war which we never conscripted ourselves into.  What support we have:  family here and abroad, our holy congregations, and the community leadership, is also frought and under strain.


With so many dying, including loved ones we've lost recently, and friends and neighbours we hear are bereaved: one neighbour lost 80 family members.  It feels aweful.  We have been in morning for the last month.  I myself try and keep my spirits up but while I normally find politics enjoyable... lately it's been more of an experience of expressing my feelings of bereavement and loss, my anger, and the loss of people who political divisions have pit us as enemies when we were friends before.


I have always cared about both sides and stayed informed to quite a high level and engaged with social media.  This has translated into physical exaustion from many demonstrations.  


As a march we organise into blocks and I found myself torn between 2, these different identities.

On a recent demonstration with Jewish community and Brendan Cox, the Palestinian MP Leyla Moran, and a Tory, the organisers instructed us not to clash with the 5pm demo over at Parliament.  Of course I was there, on time, even early.  I see no contradiction in calling a ceasefire and also standing with Leyla Moran and faith leaders to recognise humanity.  If anything, my 5pm demo attendance was a service to my party as a campaigns volunteer; filming a speech and allowing it to be shared on twitter as soon as I got to upload it on my cycle ride home.

As a cyclist, anti- austerity, environmentalist, and local issues campaigner I have been dividing all my hours between the different issues forcing me to make priorities.

On rare occasions I have allowed myself to read and even relax.

Some of my reading has been to raise my consciousness as previously I've read Jews such as Naomi Klein, Noam Chomsky, and Michael Rosen.  But what about the deep library of Palestinian literature of the last 80 years?  What if I am projecting my discomfort over what happened, onto Palestinians.  As a Jew I have been target of love and messages of solidarity, as well as people calling my naive or a useful idiot.  But Palestinians don't appreciate some of my comments and I have been ejected from a union whatsapp group.  So has another member (called David) and even non Palestinian activist groups are becoming pro Palestinian allowing another Jewish friend of mine to be kicked out of a group.   This is a pattern that allows me to sit with my own discomfort but it shows a lack of spaces where pro Palestinian Jews can discuss their genuine concerns and feedback about a small amount of behavoir without blaming but just maybe to learn and raise awareness of how to be inclusive.

In this difficult time I am therefore hugely grateful to groups like Na amod which aim to join the movement for a ceasefire and to end the occupation (which protesters believe is the root cause of the violence).  Now more than ever.  Chazak - power to the people.

That Green Party Conference motion in full

 On the 4th of October 2023, the Prime Minister announced that Phase 2 of HS2 would be cancelled due to escalating costs. It is said that cancelling the Birmingham to Manchester part of HS2 would save £36bn, which is more than the £33bn that the whole scheme connecting London, Manchester, Birmingham, Leeds, Nottingham, Sheffield, and Manchester, with links to HS1 and Heathrow was originally meant to cost.

At this point it seems uncertain as to what will happen to land which was compulsory purchased for cancelled parts of the scheme.

While there are differing views in the party about HS2, we should all be able to unite and agree that this situation is a national scandal.

The most recently published board minutes for HS2 Ltd show that the Government-owned quango intended to only reveal the costs of Phase 2b of the project after Parliament had voted to approve it, reminiscent of when Ministers withheld the fact they knew HS2 could not be delivered for the then £55bn budget when MPs voted to approve Phase 1 in 2015.

As such, conference requests the Green Party Parliamentary representatives to call for a full public inquiry into the Conservative Government’s mismanagement of the project. The scope should cover:

    Lack of oversight and regulation of HS2 finances
    The mismanagement of the Euston rebuild, including the government continually redesigning that has caused billions of extra costs and left residents with a building site for years longer than necessary, and the newly announced plans to descope Euston to 6 platforms and use the land for commercial development, severely restricting the potential for future services to the North of England and Scotland
    The removal of safeguarding of the route, effectively an attempt to sabotage future governments
    The redirecting of funds from HS2 cancellation to road building schemes which is incompatible with the Climate Emergency

LGBTIQA+ History Month - suggested reading

 Barnet's local library service has kindly suggested some good books for this month.

When I was young many of these had not yet been written, weren't available, or I never got to read them.  Going to an all boys school I never even realised until today a film was released about section 28, that section 28 also effected women and girls.

So when I picked up the Transgender Issue: a call for justice by Shon Faye I was hoping to raise my level of education a little.  What I found was a great account of the history of trans in the 20th century, which I'd also seen in the disney plus series pride.  

What I don't understand about the book is why it goes to great lengths to defend JK Rowling.

Another disappointment is that while it claims to be published in 2021, its critical analysis of the Matrix through a trans lens (though the author herself isn't trans) fails to include The Matrix 4: Revolutions.

Lots of barber shops and make-up

 I have been considering how Burnt Oak's high streets are economically viable.

Thinking back to my Geography GCSE

https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/z9y47hv/revision/2

where we learned about business clusters.  Sometimes there are several banks in a row, or a closely organised group of similar shops or businesses.  In the AQA Geography UK urban change course, that is Birmingham's Balti Triangle, and clusters of high culture, universities, and so on.  (When I visited Birmingham I found that it has a rainbow themed gay village: I wonder why that is not on BBC bitesize).

Now as people shop online, where there is less stock shrinkage, that puts certain high streets in a precarious position.  How can they compete against Amazon?

The answer is; convenience shops, supermarkets, and Post Offices can be parcel hubs where parcels are consolidated and customers can come and pick up their item.  I have tried this on one occasion.  It offers the higher floorspace and choice of online shopping, and the convenience of the town centre without having to wait in for a courrier.

Town centres will still exist, but as a more social experience.  Some things are better in person such as a community pharmacy and health service, vaccinations, or women's clothes shopping where you can try things on for size.

Another way to compete is to specialise and have business clusters.  What are the strengths of Burnt Oak town centres?  Can we welcome people and make them spend time and money here, actually enjoy the area, perhaps while they are visiting their auntie!

Firstly there is the health cluster near the hospital, Burnt Oak Broadway:  A mobility scooter and accessories shop, pharmacy, GP surgery, dementia home, community centre, fusion pub restaurant, and community hospital.  There are also convenience shops, chippy and kebabs, a wildlife walk popular with people with substance use issues, and lots of new flats. Some primary schools are nearby and there is a playground near the flats.

Not far from the pub there is another pub for members only, which I tend to avoid, and other pubs further down the main road at the Hyde.  There used to be a pub in the town centre but it is now a supermarket.  Sadly drinkers have drifted away from pubs towards more reasonably priced single beers to crack open on the way home from work, or multi pack beers to pick up in the car and consume at home with friends. Perhaps some of the decline of drinking will lead to healthier lifestyles; but my experience of listening and reading comments online is that people do not feel healthy or safe.

There are many international supermarkets including at least 2 different kinds of certified Halal Butcher, a 24 hour Romanian supermarket and restaurant, middle eastern supermarkets, and a block of flats which used to be Tesco.  There are rumours of a new Tesco.  There are also budget supermarkets but the main ones are out of town: Lidl (in Harrow Edgware) and ASDA (in Brent).  For posh supermarkets these are also elsewhere.  Upmarket shops moved long ago to places like Brent Cross.  In the old days there was a Saturday market.

Special shops in Burnt Oak include a good number of Afro hair shops and specialist cosmetics outlets, located near the Jade Pharmacy, Library and council office, and GP.

Near the library there is the Liang church which has in its vicinity many community charities, a community cluster noted in an influential report.

In the middle there are a lot of cheap and cheerful homeware shops (selling items such as suitcases) and phone kiosks.  


 

There are also a fair amount of nearby churches and at least one Islamic Centre or Mosque.

As evident in Birmingham, green spaces are important and must be protected when brownfield sites could be used: such as the carpark.  There are 2 parks near the towncentre and a leisure centre, which also contains a nursery.

Barnet's long term transport strategy

 I had a few thoughts to note while reading Barnet's long term transport strategy.


Here is what the corporate plan 21-24 says about cycle routes:

"– Developing a cycle network to major destinations in the borough
without impeding busy and narrow traffic routes"

As if cycle lanes would impede anything!

Why "traffic" which I take to mean cars, is busy, is because they are in their cars and not on bikes!  Why would you say they impede traffic?

Only 1 cycle lane has been built, on the very wide A1000 road. Even then part of it was shunted onto the pavement making it unsafe and badly constructed.


"Using enforcement to increase compliance and support smooth and
safe traffic movement."

I see very little enforcement.  When I am out and about I am anxious to see cars parked on the pavement, some legally, some illegally.  Sometimes it's not just cars but vans, tipper trucks and larger vehicles too.  They block the pavement and do not smooth the journey for walking and cycling traffic.  They make the whole borough unsafe to travel.


"Promoting and continuing to roll out electric vehicle charging points
and car clubs"

Unfortunately I have not driven for years because car clubs have not reached my part of the world.  There is one van rental near Capitol Way and a car hire in Brent Cross area. There are many car dealerships which I never visit because I do not own or wish to own one. A car club on my street would encourage people to go car-free and use it for convenience when it is needed which is less than you would think.

Not all roads are council run

but many are, such as the A1000.  There are traffic signals operated by TfL.  Amazingly, the tube is maintained by the Council which explains the pigeons all over Burnt Oak tube station.

 

Urban

The West of the Borough is designed in the strategy as urban in nature with similar high population densities to inner London.  This is sneaky because inner London has been hollowed out because of unaffordable prices and empty homes.  Everyone knows that this part of the borough is suburban in nature.  The MP says so, but is quick to blame the Labour mayor and assembly for everything that Boris Johnson left behind as mayor. It is a very recent and current phenomenon that tower blocks are being built there.  In some parts, such as Stone Grove, tower blocks were actually demolished and replaced with medium rise of about 6 storeys.  That area was lucky enough to have a residents association which campaigned hard to reject plans for something taller proposed by developers.

 

Passing through

My transport campaigner friends in Haringey, Camden, and Islington have complained to me that many anti-social drivers found there have started their journey in Barnet.


Narrative

The West of the Borough has lowest car ownership, correlating with income, but suffers the most severe air pollution.  I recommend that the narrative places the residents of the West of the Borough as the active agents for change, by celebrating their work and amplifying their advocacy for the area.  Groups such as Burnt Oak Residents Association might play a role, or the organisation Living Streets which historically had a presence here.

 

Freight

The strategy does not mention that freight can be carried by e-bikes and cargo bikes.  It does not mention the Council's work on consolidation hubs for the high street, and last mile delivery.   Meanwhile Royal Mail group has dragged its feet and been left behind investments in electric vans while DPD and amazon flood the streets.  This did not stop Royal Mail paying obscene salaries and dividends.

 


Here is a photo of me moving some compost on my cargo bike from West Hendon to my compost heap in Burnt Oak.


One More Thing

I have said for years that Labour's policy on 20 mph zones is weak.  When they got into power people realised that residents do not have a single way to request the zones, it's not clear how wide they would be, and how the Council would react to any objections because some residents aren't in favour.  In the climate emergency, the Council hasn't really made the case for them, and has been delaying so badly they may as well be Tory climate deniers.  So residents have pressured them to get on with implementing some.  I would struggle to find a 20 mph scheme implemented in the 1st year of the administration.  Some roads have appeared with 20 mph on the main roads and then signs saying 30 mph on the side roads which is obviously ridiculous and residents have rightly pointed out.  What's needed is a clear process for applying for these zones with an online form.  They could be judged against criteria.  I've been saying for a long time that everywhere where people live, work, and shop, should be a 20 mph area.  It's totally unclear how wide that goes and could confuse drivers as they constantly change. (which is no bad thing)





Better Streets for Barnet - Tally Ho!

 Today I went on my first ride with a group that organises monthly group rides around our local area.

I cycle for utility reasons not for sport or leisure and am keen that the route we took, riddled with potholes, is improved for all who share these spaces, to make them safe and accessible.

The first mission was crossing from the Tally Ho triangle island on foot to the left lane, past parked cars and 2 lanes of speeding cars.


Recommendations


North Finchley:

Remove the 1 way gyratory system, widen pavements and add a cycle-way to the town centre.  add safer crossings and design for a 20 mph speed limit or slower.  Add cycle phase traffic lights and bike box to allow riders to continue on the left when no traffic is coming across, while car red traffic light phases  are on.  Build more public toilets possibly in the Arts Depot which will open on a Sunday morning as pubs are not open till later.  clean the pidgeon poo off the area.  Fill in the potholes (too many to name individually).


West Finchley: create a parallel cycle quietway between the A1000 and the Dollis river green walk, connecting schools, park entrances, tube stations, and the church hall where Barnet Cyclists meets monthly!  Again 20 mph speed limits would be good value to invest in.

Parked cars allocated in the zone for residents could form a metal barrier separating a re-configured street layout with a safe space to cycle.

Street junctions would be designed for 20mph traffic to travel separately to walkers and bikes, mobility scooters, e-bikes, and electric scooters.

Parked cars blocking the cycle filter near the allotments would be dealt with in a tough manner when reported by the public 24/7.



Mill Hill East: 

Bittacy Roundabout would be dutch style.  Examples are available in many English cities and guidance called the Local Transport Note 1/20.  Bittacy Roundabout already contains a quieter segregated section of road that could be a cycleway linking Bittacy Hill and Holders Hill.  We took a quiet route to Mill Hill East via Abercourn Road.  It is one-way and should have a safe cycle lane going the other way in both directions possibly as part of a quiet-way.

We took a left down Sanders Lane via Bittacy Road.  Sanders Lane can be difficult to navigate at junctions, due to the down-hill sharp corner, road layout, fallen leaves, bollards, kerbs, and parked vehicle opposite 50 Sanders Lane.  This route avoids part of Devonshire Road and the busy roundabout which is difficult to navigate by bike.

Coming up Devonshire Road over the old railway bridge, there is some odd layout that is not cycle friendly.  Coming down there is a lot of car parking for the football at the weekend.  Going past the school, the right turn could be made safer at the mini-roundabout.  Parked vehicles at school run time make the area less safe to cycle at the very time it is needed.

Bunns Lane crosses two loud motorways and the railway bridge.  This area is dark and does not feel safe.  Walking could be improved and made brighter, safer, and less messy, between the bus stop, rail station, and the industrial estate.  The layout is bizarre along the A41 and a lot of land is dis-used and empty space which could be returned to nature or a traffic free gradual ramp or route of some sort.  There is some excellent street art there.  Flooding presents a problem here as well as car parking spaces allocated on the pavement which makes the area feel less safe on Bunns Lane and Pursley Road.

 

 

Edgwarebury

Our route took us along Hale Drive which could be 20 mph and is near 2 primary schools.  Cycle routes could be creates which will ultimately link with a new traffic free route through the Edgware Primary school Super Zone along the old rail land.  Pupils at Edgware Primary would like school streets there, less car parking around, and more green space and outdoor space to play.  But we took the current suburban route down Westway, Brook Avenue and Farm Road and past the Bank along Edgwarebury Lane where we waited at some traffic lights and crossed 5 lanes of traffic, which I recommend is improved for cyclists crossing there, with cyclist traffic lights, bike box, and good cycle parking at Mowbrey Parade shops.

We continued past the Jewish Cemeratry which has a steady flow of car traffic Sunday-Friday, and past some horses and along a bridleway, which crosses the M1 motorway.  At this point there is a concrete block which makes the cycle path inaccessible to many e-bikes, though the gate does not seem to stop fly-tippers.  This would be a good place to organise a community litter pick.

I would recommend cycle parkin for the Jewish Cemetary, which serves many local residents within a 15 minute walk or cycle journey.

The area is a great place to go on a walk but does not have pavements at this stage being Green Belt land.  It would benefit from somewhere to rest and sit after the steep hill.

 

High Barnet

 On our way back, we passed Wellhouse Lane and Wood Street, passing some wonderful Whale-bones.

I would recommend improvements to cycling to the hospital for staff who regularly cycle near their home in inner North London but have to occasionally visit Barnet General Hospital.

The junction of Wood Street and High Street is still not designed for cyclists.

I would recommend a safe crawler lane for cyclists up Barnet Hill.

Western Parade and Great North Road have an ancient lost cycleway which shows huge potential for a fantastic cycleway between High Barnet and Totteridge, but the junction outside the cinema towards New Barnet needs taking out and replacing with a public square that contains the abandoned building and greenery.  At this point I note John's Cycles, a cycle repair shop, which will benefit from increased trade when the A1000 is made safe.

Whetstone

After Farnham close and Friern mount drive, the A1000 cycleway would cross from the West to the East side of the road.  The design of this crossing would retain some car parking spaces but re-design the space so it does not put them in a place that does not pose a danger to cyclists.

At this point I would come off the A1000 down St Margrets Road avoiding the nasty junctions, or turn right at Kwik fit down woodhouse lane towards the quiet way and past the church hall where there is a drop off for Finchely Food Bank and where Barnet Cyclists meet.

Writing to the Hendon MP for the Nth time about the NHS

 Dear Matthew Offord,

I am writing to you about the NHS crisis.

As you may know, the number of elective NHS operations such as eyes, that have been farmed out to private companies, has dramatically increased.  This has led to an increased number of deaths according to a study by Oxford University.  The Conservatives have carried on where Labour began.
While Labour's Health Secretary Alan Milburn MP found himself conveniently working for a fund that invests in private health companies, their shadow health secretary was quoted in the media promising to put private companies to the task of clearing the backlog.

At Barnet hospital, Labour started a 33 year PFI project which bleeds money.  I have proposed a solar deal which will re balance the hospital's bills by providing solar energy for the community's benefit using land and infrastructure that is already on site.

This is not just about privatisation.  The solution clearly lies in social care.  The £14 billion over the next 2 years promised by the conservatives comes nowhere near the promises to nurses that you made, in your manifesto, for 40 new hospitals, many new doctors and nurses, and so on.  As the budget consultation approaches let's be honest that there needs to be a lot more funding for social care for disabled people.  This will allow carers the decent pay of £15 an hour they deserve while they risked their lives in the pandemic to keep their essential work going.  There needs to be enough funding for a 20% lift in nurses average pay too, to allow them to afford the fuel to get to work, and to be able to feed themselves.

This is urgent.  There are people wetting themselves in emergency departments, that are overwhelmed with these patients.

Could I suggest you reply to me once you have written to the health secretary which I asked you to do in a previous email.

Yours sincerely,

Ben Samuel